OPINION
Europe and America Belong Together and Britain Does Not Have to Chose Between the US and the EU

By Denis MacShane

25 years ago a US president paid a state visit to UK. President George W Bush was seen by many Labour MPs and a broader liberal-left community as a war-mongering moron after he invaded Iraq in a futile search for weapons of mass destruction in response to the thousands killed in Manhattan.

            My friend, Christopher Hitchens, the Owen Jones of this day, an Oxford educated ultra-left writer and speaker, was delighted. He had written endlessly about Saddam Hussein’s cruelties as a dictator whose preferred method in holding his country together was to detain, torture, execute opponents by placing explosives around the neck of a victim and blowing them to pieces as well as to launch an invasion of Iran supported at the time by Washington.

            The US sent billions of dollars of military and economic aid to Iraq and its cruel dictator. But there was no evidence that a single cent  was sent by Saddam to Osama Bin Laden the author of 9/11 and his Al Qaeda terrorist network which was financed by rich donors in the Gulf states whose kings, princes and emirs turned a blind eye to Bin Laden ‘scrusade against Jews, Shias or any aspect of western democracy.

             Tony Blair relied on MI6 and its chief, Sir Richard Dearlove,  who still signed letters in green ink with “C” and later lent his status to the Brexit campaign. The Chilcot Inquiry later condemned his use of faulty sources and failure to check on the sources the government used to justify the invasion.

            Today it is Donald Trump who is in the firing line of left-liberal fury which at times simply ignores Iran’s anti-Jewish hate and open calls for the elimination of Israel and Jewish existence in the Middle East.

            Trump is accused of being the useful idiot of Israel’s far-right prime minister Bibi Netanyahu who has longed for a super-power attack on Iran.

            He has got one but it has turned into a global Trump recession  casting fear into every household and business in the world.

            Trump in turn has turned on  US allies insulting their leaders like Sir Keir Starmer or even the wife of France’s president Macron.

            All of Europe is aghast except Hungary’s pro-Putin prime minister Viktor Orban who this week will host a visit by the US Vice President JD Vance to try and keep Orban in power following next Sunday’s election.

            25 years ago the opposition to George W Bush’s sending US armies to invade Iraq and Afghanistan produced a similar negative rection from European leaders like France’s Jacques Chirac or Germany’s Gerhard Schröder who refused military backing as long as Bush’s war defied international law as the UN refused to vote for it.

            But Bush reacted quite differently from Trump. Far from insulting the European leaders who refused to send their citizens of die in the American invasions, Bush played up the need for Europe and America to keep working together.

            He came to London in 2003 and told MPs and ambassadors: “My nation welcomes the growing unity of Europe, and the world needs America and the European Union to work in common purpose for the advance of security and justice.”

            Thirty years earlier, US President Lyndon Jonnson had taken the same approach when European leaders like Charles de Gaulle attacked US intervention in Vietnam to try unsuccessfully to prevent the  nation from turning into a fully-fledged communist police state.

            Johnson instructed his aides to say nothing about de Gaulle’s anti-American tirades saying that France and America were old allies and even older friends and the current Gaullist lectures and finger-wagging would soon fade away.

            Sir Keir Starmer is surely right to follow the LBJ example and not stoop into the gutter of exchanging insults with Trump.

            And those like me who think Britain’s isolationist rejection of friendship and partnership with fellow European nations should not wish for some kind of rupture into a new 2 camp – US versus Europe – world.

            America was born out of Europe and the values of democracy, rule of law, freedom of expression still form a transatlantic bond the ending of which will only benefit Putin, Ji, and the world that rejects democracy and core human freedoms.

Dr Denis MacShane was Minister of State for Europe and for relations with the United States in the last Labour government.

About the author

Related Post

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

WordPress Cookie Plugin by Real Cookie Banner